(The title of this post was inspired by Diane Ravitch’s book, The Death and Life of the Great American School System)
Creativity in education is dying a slow and painful death. From the signing of NCLB, to the carrot and stick approach of Race to the Top, there are numerous reasons for the grave state of creativity and innovation in American schools. Our education system is far too politicized. Who is to blame for the homogenization of the American school system? The hard answer is that we are all to blame.
Railing against the system is a futile pursuit for those who work closest with children. It is a poor use of our time and energy. If teachers and parents are waiting for the federal and state government to get education right, they will be waiting a long time. Few state and federal initiatives have ever led to significant gains in student achievement. While the Civil Rights Act of 1972, the ESEA of 1975, Title IX, and the Bilingual Education Act improved educational access for under-represented groups, they did not lead to significant increases in academic achievement.
The current drama regarding the Common Core is a colossal waste of time for those on both sides of the argument. Standards are a starting point for teaching. They provide direction and structure, but they are not the bar. When teachers focus solely on the standards, they leave something very important out of the equation, the students. This is where creativity is lost. Teachers must have the freedom to teach based on the needs of the students in front of them, not on a preconceived notion of where students should be.
So, what’s the solution for bringing creativity and innovation back to the classroom? The solution is as simple as it is complex. Let our teachers teach. Train them, support them, pay them well, and let them do their job. The federal and state government needs to step back and out of a profession they are mostly untrained for.
What would happen if all states were funded fairly using an accepted formula that is not tied to incentives and compliance? What would happen if states and local education agencies had the discretion to use funds as they see fit? Teacher creativity and innovation would likely explode and rigor in the classroom could truly be raised.
An educational revolution is unnecessary. Schools need not rebel against the implementation of the Common Core State Standards. In fact, their response should be just the opposite. Teachers and principals should become experts on the new standards. Schools should embrace the standards with a critical eye and make adjustments based on their knowledge of good instruction.
With a strong knowledge of the standards, schools can approach instruction through multi-disciplinary, cross-curricular means. Creativity and innovation can be returned to the classroom by teachers who are able to provide meaningful learning that is connected to real-life applications. The possibilities are endless when teachers are set free to use their knowledge and experience.